On Tuesday, Wolfe Research began coverage on shares of Instacart (NASDAQ:CART) with a Peerperform rating, expressing concerns over the company's growth prospects. The research firm highlighted skepticism regarding Instacart's ability to achieve accelerating Gross Transaction Value (GTV) growth that surpasses the industry's low double-digit percentage range.
The firm pointed out challenges Instacart may face in gaining significant market share within a highly competitive environment, especially as retailer exclusivity ends, potentially limiting the upside to the company's take rate potential. Additionally, if GTV growth remains within the mid to high single-digit percentage range, it could lead to a similar growth trajectory for advertising revenue, which in turn might affect the company's margin expansion.
Instacart's stock valuation was also a subject of analysis. Wolfe Research set a fair value (FV) range for Instacart's stock between $26 and $43, based on a set of enterprise value to EBITDA (EV/EBITDA) multiples ranging from 7 to 11 times the fiscal year 2025 estimated earnings.
This valuation is consistent with the median of the comparable group, which stands at 9.2 times, taking into account Instacart's modest top-line growth paired with attractive margins. The firm's assessment comes as Instacart's shares trade at 8.8 times the 2025 EBITDA estimate, with a current stock price of $34.57.
In other recent news, Instacart has been at the center of several significant developments. KeyBanc Capital Markets initiated coverage on Instacart, assigning a Sector Weight rating and acknowledging the company's leadership in the grocery delivery sector. However, they indicated potential challenges ahead, suggesting a possible moderation in Instacart's revenue expansion.
Instacart has also been making notable strides in its business operations. The company has launched a same-day delivery service in partnership with Sally Beauty (NYSE:SBH), a prominent hair color and care retailer, broadening its offerings to more than 2,200 locations across the United States.
In addition, Instacart has expanded its partnership with Rite Aid (NYSE:US90274J5618=UBSS) to offer Electronic Benefits Transfer (EBT) card payments for the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) online, improving access to groceries and pantry essentials for customers with SNAP benefits.
In a move to enhance its financial flexibility, Instacart authorized a $500 million stock repurchase following the completion of a previous $1 billion program. Furthermore, in collaboration with The Home Depot (NYSE:HD), the company launched a nationwide same-day delivery service, further diversifying its offerings.
As a response to these developments, Loop Capital and BMO Capital Markets have raised Instacart's stock target, citing factors such as reduced share count, improved earnings estimates, and accelerated growth in Gross Merchandise Volume.
These are the recent developments in Instacart's ongoing business activities.
InvestingPro Insights
InvestingPro data sheds light on Instacart's financial health and market performance, offering valuable insights for investors. The company's market cap stands at a robust $9.19 billion, and despite a negative P/E ratio of -4.16, reflecting recent challenges, the gross profit margin remains impressive at 74.44% for the last twelve months as of Q1 2024. This high margin aligns with the company's strong fundamentals, as indicated by a significant gross profit of $2.31 billion. Additionally, Instacart's aggressive share buyback program and its cash reserves exceeding debt showcase proactive management and financial prudence. With analysts expecting net income growth this year and four analysts revising their earnings upwards for the upcoming period, the outlook for profitability appears positive.
InvestingPro Tips suggest that Instacart's financial strategy and potential for income growth are key factors to consider. The company's liquid assets surpassing short-term obligations and a large price uptick of 45.44% over the last six months indicate a robust financial position and investor confidence. Moreover, while the company does not pay dividends, the high shareholder yield is a testament to its commitment to returning value to shareholders. For more detailed analysis and additional tips, investors can explore InvestingPro's comprehensive insights, where there are 11 more tips available, all of which can be accessed with a special offer using the coupon code PRONEWS24 for up to 10% off a yearly Pro and a yearly or biyearly Pro+ subscription.
This article was generated with the support of AI and reviewed by an editor. For more information see our T&C.