On Wednesday, Deutsche Bank (ETR:DBKGn) adjusted its stance on Five Below (NASDAQ:FIVE), downgrading the stock from Buy to Hold and slashing the price target to $79 from the previous $155. The decision follows a period of significant underperformance by Five Below, with its shares dropping 64% year-to-date, contrasting with the S&P 500's 17% gain over the same period.
The downgrade was influenced by various factors affecting the discount retailer's financial outlook. Deutsche Bank expressed concerns about several issues including the sudden change in CEO, a downward trend in sales, a decrease in new store productivity, and merchandising that is deemed less compelling. While the firm acknowledged that the business model is not broken, it highlighted the challenges that interim CEO Ken Bull will face in his new role.
Ken Bull, who has been with the company for approximately 20 years in various leadership capacities and currently serves as the COO, is well-acquainted with Five Below's operational model. However, Deutsche Bank anticipates that resolving the company's self-inflicted problems could be a time-consuming process. The bank also foresees potential new investments in product pricing and loss prevention strategies under the new management.
Additional concerns raised by Deutsche Bank include the potential impact of new tariffs and increasing freight costs, which contribute to the overall uncertainty surrounding Five Below's margin outlook and earnings power. Furthermore, the bank sees risks to the company's growth trajectory due to heightened competition, declining store productivity, and ongoing negative same-store sales performance.
This article was generated with the support of AI and reviewed by an editor. For more information see our T&C.