Benzinga - by Shanthi Rexaline, Benzinga Editor.
Tesla, Inc. (NASDAQ:TSLA) shares staged a recovery from an eight-month low on Monday, sparking a divergence in opinions between CEO Elon Musk and investors, as well as analysts, regarding the electric vehicle maker’s future outlook.
What Happened: Musk, responding to an X post on Sunday that highlighted Tesla’s annual revenue surpassing entertainment giant Disney Co.’s (NYSE:DIS) in 2023, praised the achievement with a modest “It's a start.”
Tesla reported $96.77 billion in revenue for 2023, a 19% annual increase, outpacing Disney’s $88.90 billion for the fiscal year ending Sept. 30, 2023.
It's a start— Elon Musk (@elonmusk) January 29, 2024
Despite robust revenue growth, Tesla’s performance fell short of Wall Street expectations in the third and fourth quarters. Slowing electric vehicle adoption and economic uncertainties led to lower demand, with near-term guidance indicating a significant drop in 2024 volume growth. The company attributed this to preparations for launching its next-generation budget model EV.
Tesla faced its second consecutive quarterly earnings per share miss, with EV price cuts impacting margins. Meanwhile, Disney grappled with challenges such as depressed park attendance, lackluster streaming business performance, and a less-than-rosy box-office showing despite bringing back longtime CEO Bob Iger who implemented a turnaround plan.
The comparison between Tesla and Disney also comes against the backdrop of Musk taking potshots at the Mouse House for its decision to yank away ads from X in response to Musk liking anti-Semitic posts on the platform.
The Market’s Response: Following fourth-quarter results, Tesla’s stock experienced a 12% slump on Thursday. This is the longest losing streak since 2016, a period before the launch of the Model 3, a Bloomberg report said. Adam Sarhan, founder of 50 Park Investments, is bearish on the company, the report said. "There's no floor in this stock in the near term,” he reportedly said. “Investors are scratching their heads. If Tesla is lowering its forecast and is not bullish in the near term, why should investors be bullish.”
The stock built on the gains on Monday before ending up 4.19% at $190.93, according to data from Benzinga Pro.
Tesla’s market capitalization has dwindled from a peak of $1.24 trillion in early 2022 to around $607 billion. So far in January alone, its market cap eroded by $182 billion. Analysts, including Tesla bull Gary Black, have adjusted their outlooks, with calls for management clarity and strategic shifts to revive the stock.
Chart courtesy of Y Charts
Analyst Perspectives: While Wedbush analyst Daniel Ives expressed disappointment over Tesla’s management’s lack of near-term clarity, he remains optimistic about its long-term potential. The stock was removed from Wedbush’s “Best Ideas List.”
Future Fund’s Gary Black outlined a blueprint for a stock rebound, suggesting strategies like discontinuing price cuts, updating progress on the next-gen EV, advancing full self-driving to Level-3 automation, initiating a $10 billion buyback over three years, and implementing a mass communications strategy to transition ICE car owners to EVs.
Amid Tesla’s underperformance compared to its “Magnificent Seven” tech peers, some analysts have put out thoughts about its potential exclusion from the list. Investors are closely monitoring developments, looking for signs of a sustained recovery or a protracted decline.
Read Next: Is It Time To Buy Tesla Stock After Thursday’s Bloodbath? Here’s What One Long-term Technical Chart Says.
Image via Shutterstock
© 2024 Benzinga.com. Benzinga does not provide investment advice. All rights reserved.