On Tuesday, Goldman Sachs (NYSE:GS) adjusted its stance on Morgan Stanley (NYSE:NYSE:MS), moving the investment bank's rating from "Buy" to "Neutral." The firm also reduced the price target for Morgan Stanley's shares to $105 from the previous $113.
The downgrade comes after a period of significant growth for Morgan Stanley, with its stock increasing by 214% since March 13, 2020, outperforming the S&P 500's 121% rise and a 93% gain among its large bank peers.
Goldman Sachs cited several reasons for the downgrade, noting that while Morgan Stanley has a top-tier investment bank and a leading wealth management platform that have both contributed to robust returns, the firm anticipates a shift in the investment banking cycle favoring other names.
Specifically, independent investment banks are expected to see faster capital markets growth from 2024 to 2026, given their greater focus on investment banking relative to trading. Additionally, large bank peers are currently valued lower, suggesting they may have more room to benefit from the market's recovery.
Morgan Stanley's valuation also presents concerns, trading at approximately a 2.0x price-to-earnings (P/E) premium and at around the 90th percentile of price-to-tangible book value (P/TBV) over the past decade compared to its peers.
This premium valuation, according to Goldman Sachs, could pose a downside risk, particularly as the bank has shifted to trading at a premium on the return on tangible common equity (ROTCE) versus P/TBV regression line since 2017.
The analysis also highlighted potential risks in Morgan Stanley's wealth management division, suggesting a 3% downside risk to the bank's 2025 estimated wealth net interest income (NII) and a 40 basis point margin downside compared to the Street's expectations.
This is attributed to slowing cash sorting and pressure on asset yields if interest rates decrease. Since wealth revenue constitutes a larger percentage of the bank's total revenue and wealth NII is a crucial margin driver, this could impact earnings growth.
Lastly, Goldman Sachs pointed out that after significant increases in stress capital buffer (SCB) requirements, Morgan Stanley may have limited room to expand buybacks compared to its peers. The bank's dividend payout ratio is already around 50%, versus 40% at peer banks, which could constrain the potential for near-term increases in the payout ratio.
In other recent news, Morgan Stanley is predicting a slowdown in mergers, acquisitions (M&A), and initial public offerings (IPOs) through 2024, as reported by co-president Dan Simkowitz. This projection aligns with expectations of central banks reducing interest rates, potentially reinvigorating these market activities.
Simultaneously, Wells Fargo (NYSE:WFC) has downgraded Morgan Stanley's stock rating to Underweight and reduced its price target, citing concerns about the sustainability of the bank's high performance.
In other developments, wealth management firms, including Morgan Stanley and Wells Fargo, are facing potential credit rating hits due to regulatory investigations into their cash sweep programs. This could lead to higher costs amid growing economic concerns. Meanwhile, job cuts are spreading across various sectors, including Morgan Stanley's wealth management unit, as companies navigate uncertain economic conditions.
Furthermore, Wall Street bonuses, including those for investment bankers specializing in debt underwriting and IPOs, are expected to surge by up to 35% in 2024, according to Johnson Associates. This forecast reflects robust growth in debt issuance and a vigorous IPO market.
InvestingPro Insights
As investors digest the recent rating change for Morgan Stanley (NYSE:MS), it's valuable to consider key metrics and insights that can provide a broader perspective on the company's financial health and market position. With a market capitalization of $156.17 billion and a P/E ratio of 15.74, Morgan Stanley stands as a prominent player in the Capital Markets industry. The company's commitment to shareholder returns is evident through its impressive track record of maintaining dividend payments for 32 consecutive years and raising its dividend for the last 10 consecutive years. This dedication to consistent dividend growth is further underscored by a notable 19.35% increase in dividends over the last twelve months as of Q2 2024.
Analyzing the company's performance, Morgan Stanley has demonstrated profitability with a return on assets of 0.89% in the same period. Additionally, with liquid assets surpassing short-term obligations, the firm showcases a solid liquidity position, which is a reassuring sign for investors concerned about financial stability. This financial resilience is complemented by a high gross profit margin of 86.53%, reflecting the company's efficiency in managing its cost of goods sold relative to revenue.
For those seeking more detailed analysis and additional insights, InvestingPro offers a selection of tips, including the fact that 7 analysts have recently revised their earnings estimates upwards for Morgan Stanley, indicating potential optimism about the company's future performance. Investors interested in exploring further can find additional InvestingPro Tips at https://www.investing.com/pro/MS, where there are more tips available to guide investment decisions.
This article was generated with the support of AI and reviewed by an editor. For more information see our T&C.