On Wednesday, Bernstein SocGen Group maintained a Market Perform rating for Hershey (NYSE:HSY), with a consistent price target of $205.00. The assessment follows significant fluctuations in cocoa prices since the beginning of 2023, which have seen a dramatic 165% increase due to adverse weather conditions and disease affecting crop yields.
The October to December/January cocoa harvest, which is the main growing season, is showing signs of recovery with a projected 25% year-over-year increase in harvest volumes in Ghana and the Ivory Coast. This improvement is attributed to the normalization of weather patterns after the disruptions caused by the El Niño cycle, with June and July experiencing beneficial rainfall for cocoa pod development. Despite this positive trend, cocoa inventories are still expected to face a deficit for the third consecutive year.
In response to the challenging conditions, official farmgate cocoa prices have risen by 45% in Ghana and 20-25% in the Ivory Coast. This increase, implemented through an unusual mid-year price adjustment, fell short of the 65% hike that farmers had hoped for. The lower-than-expected price rise has sparked concerns over potential cross-border smuggling and the possibility of farmers withholding crops as a form of protest, which could negatively impact cocoa exports.
Political factors could also play a role in the cocoa market, as Ghana's elections are scheduled for December 7th. Farmers may use crop withholding as leverage to pressure politicians for another increase in farmgate prices. Additionally, there is speculation that the European Union's deforestation legislation might be postponed by a year, which could alleviate some market pressures. However, this has not been confirmed, and political uncertainties continue to loom over the sector. The expectation is that the commission will approve the legislation with a delay, potentially benefiting harvest volumes.
In other recent news, financial firms have been closely monitoring Hershey's financial performance and strategic decisions. Citi, expressing caution, adjusted Hershey's price target to $181 and maintained a Sell rating. The firm anticipates that Hershey's upcoming third-quarter earnings report may not meet consensus estimates for organic sales growth and earnings per share (EPS), potentially due to weaker than anticipated performance in Hershey's North America Confectionary segment.
Analysts from Bernstein SocGen Group and UBS have also downgraded Hershey's stock, citing concerns over underwhelming chocolate volumes and overly optimistic earnings projections amidst cost pressures and uncertain demand. Meanwhile, Hershey has announced a 12% price increase on about half of its product portfolio, a move that RBC predicts will positively impact the company.
In a strategic shift, Hershey is moving away from chocolate and introducing alternative sweets such as gummies, licorice, and flavored crèmes. This change in product offerings is seen as a response to shifting consumer preferences and industry pressures. The company has also appointed Michael Del Pozzo as the new President of its U.S. Confection segment, a move expected to drive Hershey's growth initiatives within the United States.
InvestingPro Insights
As Hershey navigates the volatile cocoa market, InvestingPro data provides additional context to the company's financial position. Hershey's market capitalization stands at $37.88 billion, reflecting its significant presence in the confectionery industry. The company's P/E ratio of 20.68 suggests that investors are willing to pay a premium for its earnings, which aligns with its strong brand and market position.
InvestingPro Tips highlight Hershey's commitment to shareholder returns, noting that the company "has raised its dividend for 14 consecutive years" and "has maintained dividend payments for 54 consecutive years." This consistent dividend policy may provide some stability for investors amid cocoa price fluctuations. The current dividend yield of 2.92% could be attractive to income-focused investors.
However, it's worth noting that Hershey is "trading at a high P/E ratio relative to near-term earnings growth," which investors should consider in light of the challenges in the cocoa market. The PEG ratio of 5.26 further underscores this point, indicating that the stock may be relatively expensive compared to its growth prospects.
For those interested in a deeper analysis, InvestingPro offers 11 additional tips that could provide valuable insights into Hershey's financial health and market position.
This article was generated with the support of AI and reviewed by an editor. For more information see our T&C.