On Sunday 30th November the Swiss people will go to the polls to decide on a referendum on the Swiss Central Bank’s (the SNB) gold reserves. The proposal put forward by the right wing Swiss People’s Party would require the SNB to hold gold reserves equivalent to 20% of their total assets, all Swiss gold held with foreign central banks would need to be repatriated, and the SNB would need to commit to never selling gold in the future.
The results:
It looks like the earliest result will be out at 1300 local time on Sunday; however it depends on the region, with each Canton releasing their results at different times. Geneva’s result will be critical, it tends to give continual results as they come in, likewise, Zurich is expected to release the participation number during the day, before sending the results in the evening.*
What the polls say
The latest polls suggest that after initially polling well, in the last month support for the Yes campaign has faded. The latest opinion poll suggests that the Yes vote will only win 38%, with 47% voting no, the Yes campaign need to win over 50% of the vote to implement the proposal. According to this poll 15% of voters were undecided, so for the Yes camp to secure victory they would need to convince all of the 15% to vote Yes, which seems unlikely, in our view.
Potential reactions:
Even though the Yes camp is unlikely to win, it’s worth sketching out the various outcomes and what this could mean for FX and precious metals markets:
If the Yes vote wins:
Gold: this would mean that the SNB would need to accumulate 1,500 tonnes of gold over 5 years, which is about half of annual production. We would expect an initial jump in the gold price; however, we think any upside could fade in the days after the result as it is not clear how the SNB would increase its gold holdings. It could spread gold purchases over a long time frame, or use swaps and other derivatives to purchase gold, thus making it hard to see their footprint in the market.
FX: We think that the SNB will maintain the EURCHF peg no matter what the outcome of this weekend’s referendum as it is central to the Bank’s monetary policy strategy. However, a win for the Yes camp could put upward pressure on the CHF as its status as a safe haven kicks in, and as investors test the SNB’s resolve to maintain the EURCHF peg. We would expect the SNB to take immediate reaction after the vote to limit EURCHF downside, which could include cutting interest rates deeper into negative territory to weaken the CHF. Rates could be cut late Sunday evening/ early Sunday morning, triggering excess volatility in EURCHF and EUR crosses.
Essentially a win for the Yes camp would push Switzerland back onto the gold standard, so every time the SNB intervene to protect the 1.20 peg in EURCHF they would need to buy gold at the same time to ensure its 20% share of the balance sheet. This could trigger excess volatility for the gold market, with investors pushing up the price of gold every time EURCHF looked like it may hit 1.20. In the lead up to the vote we could see the market challenge 1.20 in EURCHF as tail risk starts to rise, thus we could see some volatility in EURCHF in the next few days, especially with the US out on holiday on Thursday and the markets are likely to remain quiet on Friday. If 1.20 is breached in the short term we expect the SNB to intervene.
The other impact could be on the EUR. The SNB holds the majority of its assets in EUR as a result of maintaining the 1.20 peg. Thus, it would need to sell EUR to boost the share of gold on its balance sheet, which could trigger another leg lower in EURUSD and leave the EUR vulnerable to further downside in the medium-term.
If the No vote wins:
This is the most likely outcome in our view; however, maintaining the status quo could still impact the markets.
Gold: This could trigger a sharp move lower on Sunday night/ Monday morning in gold as the market prices out the possibility of SNB purchases. We think that the impact will be short-lived and the mild trend higher in the price of gold will continue.
FX: We may see a relief rally in EURCHF on the back of a win for the No camp, however, we expect it to be short-lived, as the pressures on the EURCHF peg continue to build.
EURCHF and the SNB
Regardless of the outcome of Sunday’s referendum we expect the SNB to maintain the 1.20 peg as it is a central part of its monetary policy strategy. The most recent SNB statement reiterated that the Bank would buy EUR in “unlimited quantities” to protect the peg. If the Yes vote wins protecting the peg becomes trickier, as we mention above, however, the peg could still be threatened even if the Swiss people vote No.
EURCHF has been under pressure not only because of the Swiss referendum but also because of the weak Eurozone economic outlook and the prospect of QE from the central bank. By implementing the peg the SNB essentially imports the ECB’s monetary policy, so if the ECB decides to embark on QE in the coming months then the SNB will need to respond.
They could cut interest rates further into negative territory, or they may choose to intervene to show the market they are committed to keeping EURCHF above 1.20. We think that it is unlikely the SNB will move the EURCHF peg in the medium term as this would dramatically increase their already elevated share of EUR’s on their balance sheet (see figure 1).
Interestingly, there are rumours that Hungary was selling francs last week. Hungarians hold a lot of CHF-denominated mortgage debt, and may have been reducing exposure to the CHF ahead of the referendum. There is evidence that the SNB intervened to boost EURCHF on 19th November when this cross fell to 1.2009. The SNB may have intervened in small quantities of approx. CHF 2-4 billion, which seems to have worked. The release of the latest poll data on the referendum may have also added to this mini recovery.
*My thanks to Sebastian Galy at Societe Generale for his insight on the results process for this referendum. There is a good chance that we won’t know the final result until Sunday evening.
Figure 1:
Source: FOREX.com and Bloomberg
Disclaimer: The information and opinions in this report are for general information use only and are not intended as an offer or solicitation with respect to the purchase or sale of any currency or CFD contract. All opinions and information contained in this report are subject to change without notice. This report has been prepared without regard to the specific investment objectives, financial situation and needs of any particular recipient.
Any references to historical price movements or levels is informational based on our analysis and we do not represent or warrant that any such movements or levels are likely to reoccur in the future. While the information contained herein was obtained from sources believed to be reliable, the author does not guarantee its accuracy or completeness, nor does the author assume any liability for any direct, indirect or consequential loss that may result from the reliance by any person upon any such information or opinions.